STUDENTs

Lucinda Sun

SEMESTER

HS26

Acoustic Profiles

01. Lucinda’s Dorm Room 1411, Cäsar-Ritz-Strasse 1 (~14 m2)

My room, like any other dorm room, is primarily a private space for sleeping, studying, and resting. Acoustically, it is quite balanced with internally produced sounds, not dry or too reverberant. Its small size makes it feel intimate. The furniture provides absorptive surfaces that limit some reverberation, but the room remains somewhat reflective due to its predominantly hard surfaces. When it’s quiet outside, the room feels comfortable and calm. In the morning, I sometimes open the window to hear birds chirping, while at night the low hum of traffic acts as a pleasant, unobtrusive white noise.

What is most striking is how easily sound travels through the building. The concrete all around amplifies any noise made outside a bedroom as it reflects and overlaps. Sounds from the communal kitchen are particularly noticeable. The space’s large volume and high ceiling produce echo and bring muffled, reverberant conversations into my room. In the recording above, the kitchen noise drowns out my voice from inside the closet, even though the kitchen sound source is farther away. Kitchen parties get on my nerves because the noise is unpredictable and uncontrollable. Sudden high-frequency screams or screeches can startle me, while prolonged medium-frequency sounds varying in amplitude become frustrating. The dorm room takes no acoustic measures to block the outside soundscape.

The hallway produces more identifiable sounds, such as approaching footsteps and doors opening and closing. In contrast, once someone enters a neighbouring room, I cannot hear them. The closed room boundaries provide much better sound insulation. When everything is quiet, I can hear the very high-frequency, extremely low-amplitude electrical buzz from my slightly malfunctioning phone charger.

02. Bike Room, Ground Floor, Cäsar-Ritz-Strasse 1 (~151 m2)

The bike room is much larger and more communal than my dorm room. Its high ceiling, concrete walls, floor, and columns create a very reverberant acoustic environment. The many bikes provide some scattered surfaces, but there are effectively no absorbers. Unlike in my room, voices become increasingly difficult to understand as the sound source moves further away.

At the time of observation, it was nighttime and the space was quiet. The most consistent sounds were the HVAC system’s low-frequency hum and the intermittent sound of running water from the exposed overhead pipes. Occasionally, someone entering the neighbouring laundry room produced footsteps and a louder, short door-shutting sound. When one person entered while I was listening, their footsteps became a moving sound source, travelling through and echoing across the room. There were no high-frequency sounds while I was there.

Emotionally, the space sounded empty despite its abundance of bikes. It felt somewhat detached and impersonal. At the same time, the evening quiet and lack of unpredictable noises felt peaceful, while the HVAC provided a continuous acoustic baseline.

Room Acoustics

01. Lucinda’s Dorm Room (2.7 m x 5.2 m x 2.2 m)

The dorm room is a relatively small residential space with a hard architectural shell and localized absorption provided mainly by the bed and clothing. The room combines reflective concrete and painted surfaces with soft furnishings that reduce some sound reflections.

Reflective surfaces include a concrete ceiling (14 m2), wood floor (~14 m2), undulating concrete wall behind the bed and around the closet (~6 m2), glass (~2.3 m2), and other painted walls (~32.5 m2). Absorptive elements include the bed and mattress (~2 m2), pillows (.4 m2), and clothing (~3 m2).

The room’s absorptive elements are concentrated around the bed and walk-in closet. The undulating concrete surface behind the bed and on the exterior of the walk-in closet is a notable feature. Its irregular geometry may scatter sound rather than reflecting it in a single direction, although its hard cement material means that it should not be considered a significant absorber.

Expected Acoustic Character

The dorm room would likely sound moderately live, particularly at mid and high frequencies, because of its hard ceiling, floor, and walls. The bed, pillows, and clothing should reduce some reverberation, but their localized distribution means that the room is unlikely to sound completely dead.

Calculations

My calculation predicts a reverberation time of approximately 0.73 s at 500 Hz and 0.82 s at 1000 Hz, with an average of 0.78 seconds. In contrast, the online calculator gives a baseline RT60 of 1.21 s at 500 Hz and 1.35 s at 1000 Hz, with an average of 1.27 s across these two frequency bands. The online calculator predicts a reverberation time roughly 65–66% longer than my calculation. The online calculator uses the room’s basic rectangular geometry, which disregards additional interior walls or furniture. My calculation takes a more detailed approach, including clothing, bedding, and other objects in the room. These contribute absorption beyond the six principal surfaces of the rectangular room. Including them increases the total absorption area, which reduces the predicted reverberation time according to Sabine’s equation.

RT60 = (0.23-0.03)3 = 0.6 seconds

The measured RT60 of 0.6 seconds is relatively close to the calculated value of 0.78 seconds, though the calculated value is 0.18 seconds longer. One possible explanation is that the absorption coefficients used in the calculation were not entirely accurate. Estimated values were assigned to the mattress, pillows, and clothing, and their actual sound absorption may be greater than assumed. Other factors, such as desks, chairs, and smaller objects, may also have been overlooked or simplified when describing the room’s content.

Measurement conditions may have contributed to the discrepancy. Background noise could have made the sound decay harder to read. Human error may also have influenced the measured result. I manually interpreted the sound decay in Audacity by drawing approximate lines across the graph to estimate the decay slope and the time required for a 20 dB decrease. This value was then multiplied by three to extrapolate RT60. Since both the linear approximation and the identification of the 20 dB decrease were rough estimates, small inaccuracies in reading the graph could have affected the final value.

02. Bike Room (6.28 m x 24.12 m x 3 m)

The bike room is a large, elongated space with concrete walls, floor, ceiling, and cylindrical columns. Unlike the dorm room, the bike room contains effectively no soft materials. Its acoustic character is defined by hard, reflective surfaces.

Reflective surfaces include the concrete floor (~151 m2), concrete walls (~160.3 m2), concrete ceiling (~151 m2), glass (22.1 m2), and cylindrical concrete pillars (~33.8 m2).

There are virtually no absorbers, built-in or brought-in. The concrete enclosure therefore dominates its acoustic response. The bicycles introduce geometric complexity, scattering sound and interrupting some reflection paths. Similarly, the cylindrical concrete pillars arrayed within the room redirect sound in different directions as well.

Expected Acoustic Character

The bike room would likely sound highly reverberant and potentially echo-y as its large volume and extensive hard concrete surfaces provide little sound absorption. While its elongated geometry encourages repeated reflections along the room, the bicycles and cylindrical pillars scatter some sound and may soften distinct echoes.

Calculations

My calculation predicts a reverberation time of approximately 5.22 s at 500 Hz and 5.77 s at 1000 Hz, with an average of 5.5 seconds. In contrast, the online calculator gives an RT60 of 10.05 s at 500 Hz and 7.54 s at 1000 Hz, with an average of 8.79 s. Overall, the online calculator predicts a reverberation time approximately 60% longer than my calculation.

This discrepancy is partly due to the limitations of the online calculator. It only allowed me to assign one material to each wall, meaning that it could not accurately represent surfaces containing both concrete and glass elements. Furthermore, I could not add the additional concrete pillars as separate surfaces. As a result, the calculator’s representation of the room differs from the actual space and cannot fully account for the individual surface areas and their respective absorption coefficients.

RT60 = (1.6-0.17)3 = 4.29 seconds

The measured RT60 of 4.29 seconds is 1.21 seconds shorter than the calculated average of 5.5 seconds. As in the previous Dorm Room case, this discrepancy may partly be due to inaccurate absorption coefficients and human error when manually estimating the sound decay in Audacity.

Additionally, some features of the bike room were oversimplified or omitted. The bicycles were excluded because their complex shapes made their surface area difficult to estimate. Wall extrusions containing electrical systems and ceiling installations, including ducts and metal pipes, were also disregarded. These elements may affect sound absorption and scattering.

Acoustic Treatment

The dorm room would benefit more from acoustic treatment. Exterior noise entering the room can remain noticeably loud and reverberant. Although the measured RT60 of 0.6 seconds is not especially high for a bedroom, reducing reverberation could lessen intrusive noises by limiting the buildup of reflected sound. However, interior acoustic treatment would not prevent exterior noise from entering the room; improving sound insulation around windows and doors would be more effective for that purpose.

I would propose adding approximately 4–6 m² of sound-absorbing material, such as acoustic panels or thick fabric-covered absorbers, on the wall behind the bed and on other large, relatively unobstructed wall surfaces. It may also help to bring more furniture, such as a carpet, into the room. The target RT60 is 0.4–0.5 seconds, suitable for a small bedroom. Although the aim is to lessen reverberation, the room should not become excessively acoustically dead.

©

Architectural Acoustics

Department of Architecture logo
ETH Zurich logo